Series: Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (DS9)
Episode: 2.5 Cardassians (October 25, 199)
Rating: 4/5
Redshirt Status: 0/1/3.5
Notable Guest Stars:
Robert Mandan (Kotan Pa’Dar)- Mandan was best known for his roles on shows such as The Search for Tomorrow and Soap. He also appeared in several well-known sitcoms as a guest star such as All in the Family, Maude, and Sanford and Son.
Terrence Evans (Proka) – Evans appeared last season as a mute farmhand in the episode Progress. He will later play a role on Voyager.
Vidal Peterson (Rugal) – Peterson was a child actor, and this was his last credit according to IMDB. He appeared in 1991 in TNG, and also appeared in The Thorn Birds, which has quite a few Star Trek Alum in it.
Returning is Andrew Robinson (Elim Garak), Rosalind Chao (Keiko O’Brien) and Marc Alaimo (Gul Dukat).
Review:
Read more: The Rewatch 237: CardassiansThis episode brings up an interesting issue. After decades of being on Bajor, Cardassia evacuated the planet, leaving behind several orphan children. One of those children was Rugal, who was adopted and raised by a pair of Bajoran parents since he was 4 or 5 years old.
Rugal gets everyone’s attention when he bites Garak. Which I find really odd given the age of the child. They keep referring to him as a child, so I am assuming he is meant to be younger then the actual actor (who was 26). I had assumed he was at least 14, possibly as old as 16. It seems a bit old for that kind of behavior. In context clues suggest he may just be twelve but it still doesn’t seem age appropriate. Not that I have much sympathy for Garak – he did invade Rugal’s space and touched him without permission.
Someone accuses Rugal’s adoptive father of abuse, and so Sisko has to take things into his own hands and complete an investigation. Rugal is taken out of the care of his father and put in the care of Keiko O’Brien instead.
As it turns out, while there is a real problem with Cardassian children left behind on Bajor, Dukot and Pa’Dar aren’t really concerned. Pa’Dar mentions how important family is and to be found out as a neglectful parent is humiliation at its largest. Dukat wants him to be humiliated as he is Rugal’s father and therefore “abandoned” him despite the fact that Pa’Dar thought him dead for years. So this wasn’t about the “cause” for Dukot. But Pa’Dar seems almost dismissive of returning any of the orphans other then his own son.
Rugal wants to remain with his Bajoran parents, and his wants are ignored. Sisko returns him to his biological parent since he could find no reason Pa’Dar shouldn’t have his son back. I’m not sure I agree but what do you think?
Interesting Notes:
- Story by Gene Wolande & John Wolande
- Teleplay by James Crocker
- Directed by Cliff Bole
- This is the first time we hear the Cardassian name for DS9: Terok Nor. Trust me, we will hear this plenty of times in the future.
- Exploration of Cardassian Culture
- The nice thing about DS9 is it doesn’t shy away from showing the aftereffects of war. How Bajor is still unstable, and just finding its feet after decades of occupation. How there were orphans on both sides. Although the Cardassians still come off as a horrible people in general.
- I like the showing of Miles O’Brien working on his prejudice. A lot of times on TV shows you have a character who has a epiphany/awaking to an issue and suddenly they loose all their bad ways. Miles shows here that it is something you have to keep working on. One thing I like about Post-Roddenberry Trek is that Humanity is still in need of work. Some of the TOS and early TNG episodes are so “We are beyond this”
Cons:
- Why is Cirroc Lofton given Regular credit status if they don’t plan on actually using him? ( I actually had this from the last episode but the situation still remains. Particularly for this episode as there was a perfect reason to have him around with Rugal).
- I’m not sure this episode had a satisfactory ending.
Screencap credited to TrekCore